Should you give a promise ring back?

If a promise is broken, it is proper to return the promise ring just as a couple would return an engagement ring in the case of a broken engagement. If neither individual wants to keep the ring it could be sold and the money split.

When you break off an engagement who keeps the ring?

giver
If the engagement is broken, the giver gets the ring back, regardless of the reasons for the split. This is similar to the no-fault divorce approach of family law.

What does a promise ring stand for in a relationship?

In the simplest of terms, a promise ring is a step up from dating. It shows the world that your heart belongs to another and that you’re devoted to protecting and nurturing that relationship. These days, a promise ring is most commonly given as a precursor to an engagement, but that is not always the case.

Why do some women never give back their engagement rings?

Not all women give the ring back, in my 31yrs of jewelry experience, most women do not give the ring back. The ones that do have a variety of reasons. Some give it back because they don’t want a reminder of the old relationship, some feel obligated since they didn’t go through with the marriage, some feel that the other person needs the money.

What to do if your ex-fiance Won’t give your ring back?

If your ex-fiance feels threatened or pushed into giving the ring back, it could potentially cause legal issues in the future. Explain to her why you believe you are entitled to the ring and kindly ask for its return. Listen to what she has to say and be sensitive. In most mutual break-ups an agreement can be made when both parties are civil.

When to return an engagement ring to the giver?

In this article we will examine both common etiquette answers and provide a thorough state-by-state rundown of all the relevant engagement ring laws. Traditionally, an engagement ring is returned to the giver if the bride-to-be initiated the break-up or if it was mutual.

What happens to the engagement ring when the engagement is called off?

Since the woman usually has possession of the ring when the engagement is called off, it is the person who proposed to her who will have to take some action if they believe they are entitled to get the ring back. If the ring-giver seeks the court’s assistance in getting the ring back, the outcome will depend on which law that state follows.