Is The Richard Donner Cut better?

Lester’s version is more “fun,” while Donner’s cut remains fairly intense throughout. There is any number of versions of this action sequence online that incorporates footage from both versions, and it’s probably fair to say that some combination of the two gets the job done better than either one on its own.

Which cut of Superman II is better?

Lester’s Cut is More Polished Had Richard Donner completed the Superman sequel back in 1979, it very likely would have been a better film than what Lester ultimately made — but 2006’s The Donner Cut is simply the best one could do 26 years later.

Is Superman 2 The Richard Donner Cut canon?

In 2006, Warner Bros. worked with Donner to restore his own vision to Superman II, releasing his cut of the film. The result is an incomplete movie patched together from alternate takes and even some screen tests.

Why was Donner fired from Superman?

Donner was fired while filming “Superman II” (1980), amid conflict with producers Alexander and Ilya Salkind. He complained that he had never received a budget or schedule for the movies, and he was replaced by Richard Lester, who reshot most of the sequel.

Why Richard Donner left Superman?

The Salkinds felt their director had gone over budget, Donner felt the producers were trying to make the film campier, wanting co-producer Pierre Spengler removed. The director left the production and was replaced by Richard Lester, who’d acted as a mediator on the original production.

Why was Donner fired?

What is the difference between Superman 2 and the Richard Donner cut?

Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut is a 2006 superhero film that is a re-edit of the 1980 film Superman II. More than half of Lester’s footage filmed for Superman II has been removed from the film and replaced with Donner footage shot during the original principal photography from 1977–1978.

Why was Donner fired Superman 2?

How old is Richard Donner?

91 years (1930–2021)
Richard Donner/Age at death

Is the Donner Cut of Superman II worth watching?

Theatrical cut is THE cut to see. The Donner cut is an interesting after thought, but obviously a spiteful one. Following the ravings of various Richard Donner fans, I just spent two highly unsatisfactory hours of my life watching the Donner cut of Superman II.

What is the difference between “Superman II” and the alternate versions?

At its essence, the alternate version of the Richard Donner Cut of “Superman II” is fundamentally the same as the released version by and large, but it also has its share of differences as well. This analysis will break down the differences between the two versions and attempt to lay bare why those differences occurred.

Did John Williams do the Superman II Lester cut?

Now I have to pony up the dough for the I-IV box set (with all the extra features and SUPERMAN RETURNS) AGAIN. Those clever capitalistic bastards…:) John Williams didn’t do the Superman II Lester cut. Ken Thorne rescored using the Williams themes.

What do you think of Richard Lester’s book Richard Donner?

Richard Lester wisely made judicious cuts to much of Richard Donner’s material, producing a much tighter narrative. I cannot see the value of adding these cuts back in. I would not say the enterprise was pointless and admire the dedication required to locate, catalogue and edit all the unused material.