Why is Apple butterfly keyboard so bad?

But those benefits were eclipsed by the butterfly keyboard’s many faults. The biggest is simply that the design was unreliable. The mechanism was so fragile that seemingly any little piece of debris or grit could break a key, keeping it from working or making it type double letters.

What is the problem with butterfly keyboard?

The suit, which claims that “the low-travel design of the butterfly mechanism makes the keys prone to fail when minute amounts of dust or debris enter the sensitive area beneath the switch,” includes 11 consumers from California, Massachusetts, New York, Illinois, Florida, Washington, New Jersey, and Michigan, and …

Why did Apple ditch the butterfly keyboard?

Despite several design revisions, Apple was forced to roll out a free program to replace broken butterfly keyboards, in what proved to be a rare design failure for the proud company, eroding both the brand’s design reputation and customer confidence. …

Is the MacBook butterfly keyboard that bad?

The butterfly keyboard was, and still is, pretty bad. So many, in fact, that Apple eventually issued an apology to users affected by faulty butterfly keyboards and set up a free repair program. It was also called one of “the worst products in Apple history” by prominent Apple blogger Jon Gruber.

Is butterfly keyboard really bad?

It is bad, but in another way than you may think of. The keys have a really short travel distance and as I’m coming from a lot of years of mechanical keyboard use, at first it seemed horrible but I’ve adjusted to it just fine.

Can you replace butterfly keyboard?

You’re laptop probably has a pesky butterfly keyboard inside. Luckily, there’s a hardware fix that will cost you nothing. Better still, because of how Apple has designed its MacBooks, other hardware gets replaced simultaneously.

How do you fix a stuck butterfly on a keyboard?

Using two fingers, simply give the bottom of the laptop a bunch of firm taps in the area of the problematic key. Right the laptop and set it down. Push the problematic key repeatedly. It should pop back into place, if it didn’t during the inverted step.

Does Apple still use butterfly keyboard?

Apple did away with the butterfly keyboards starting in 2019. “Yes, it helped introduce thinner, lighter, more portable MacBooks, but we can safely say the butterfly keyboard did not ever spark joy,” CNET reviewer Dan Ackerman wrote of the keyboards last year.

Can you replace butterfly keyboard with scissor?

No, the parts and design of the laptops are completely different. If you want a keyboard with the scissor mechanism, then you need to purchase a new laptop which utilizes the scissor mechanism.

Why do people hate butterfly keyboards?

Butterfly keyboard should have died years ago The MacBook butterfly keyboard is thinner, but less reliable. The MacBook butterfly keyboard serves as an example of how very hard product design can be. The keyboard design needs less space beneath the keys compared to a regular scissor-switch mechanism.

Does Apple replace Butterfly keyboard with scissors?

Sorry the mechanics of the butterfly keys is very different from the older (magic) scissor keys Apple is now using again. There is no way to effectively convert the 2019 and older system to the Magic Keyboard keys. If you really want the better keyboard then you’ll need to buy a 2020 16” or 13” system.

Did the butterfly keyboard hurt Apple’s reputation?

The butterfly keyboard hurt Apple’s reputation precisely because the outlines of its problems and Apple’s response to them lined up with some of the biggest complaints people have about the company. Earlier, I called Apple’s attempts to save the butterfly keyboard obstinate, but a less charitable way of putting it is simply to call it hubris.

Can you fix a butterfly keyboard on a MacBook?

Now that all butterfly keyboards are covered, customers with an affected machine will have no problem getting a fix. Apple is prioritizing MacBook and MacBook Pro keyboard repairs and requiring Apple retail staff to perform the repairs in store rather than sending machines off to a repair facility, which takes days.

Why do Apple keyboards have butterfly switches?

Apple swapped to a butterfly mechanism to make a thinner keyboard, which is possible because each key moves less when pressed so less space is needed.

Why do butterfly keyboards fail so hard?

Because of the butterfly key’s ‘V’ shape, it’s easier for food, debris, and general dirt to get underneath the mechanism — something that’s prevented (a bit more at least) from happening with an ‘X’ shape. To put it simply, this issue with shit getting under the keys is the reason the butterfly keyboard has failed so hard.